What Happens When the Monsters of H. P. Lovecraft Turn Out to Be Real?

When I began working on PROJECT MARTENSE, I confronted a fundamental question: Does Lovecraft’s fiction exist within the world of the story, or do the horrors of the Cthulhu Mythos emerge in a world that has never heard of them?
Either option presents exciting pros and cons. On the one hand, telling a tale where the world encounters Lovecraft’s cosmic horrors with no frame of reference sounds like loads of fun! On the other hand, Lovecraft’s Cthulhu and other extradimensional entities are part of pop culture, and it would be hard to resist not playing with that on a metafictional level.
And on a third hand, I get annoyed when I read a book or watch a movie where characters encounter creatures like vampires, werewolves, or zombies, for example, and act as if they themselves have never come across these critters on Netflix, which always yanks me out of the experience.
Which is why I decided that in the tale I’m telling, yes, Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos exists. Many people know of Lovecraft, some own the tentacled plushies, and, more importantly, some, like our occultists, have incorporated the Cthulhu Mythos into their ritual magick.